This is a short but useful discussion about how to give students a good reading assignment.

As people might know, reading texts in Philosophy is always tough because all the texts that students have to face are the most great but difficult literature in history. However, it is not a good idea to drop this tough task because without reading the original text, one will not get the sense of the idea and could not learn the real thought and the proceeding of the philosopher's argument genuinely.

The author of this text considers the problems that the students face and the practical problems that the instructor will face when they are giving reading assignment. There are students who want to read the literature but feel unable to do so; there are students who feel like it useless to read the original texts because the main ideas of the argument will be covered in class by instructor; and there are also students who just do not like reading any texts at all.

The instructor should consider various situations and make a plan that should fit as many students as possible. How to let students understand the text is not a question of how to tell something directly to the students, but a question of how to make students develop their own ability to read and digest the texts. The authour quoted  "professors often must substitute their strong reading skills for the students' inadequate ones. This produces a vicious cycle: inadequate student preparation, commendable professorial clarification, even less student preparation" (16). I think this notion covers one of the most important issues in education, namely, teaching people how to think all by their own.  The author also thinks it is better to make the students realize that reading texts before class is not useless. He also recommends taking a quiz among students before class in order to check whether they have done the reading.

There is another dimension which is practical in giving assignment, which the author also mentions, that is, giving more concrete instructions to students as regards to how to read those assigned texts. It is a small but a very helpful tip, because there are lots of hardworking students, and they are always trying to finish all of the reading but always feel upset at doing so because they could not finish reading all the time. The instructor should give some tips for reading, such things as skipping some paragraphs, or putting more focus on certain ideas and logical proceeding. Also, it is better to have the reading text being relevant to the life experience of students, the author suggests, because this will intrigue students' interest in reading them.

In sum, this short passage is quite condense but full of information and ideas which are of help specifically for the philosophy teaching. I believe it also offers some hints for other disciplines.

Contruibuted by Jie Yin

Dec 06, 2009